09.01.1960 Blackpool FC - Mansfield Town 3:0
Bournemouth and Boscombe Athletic - York City 1:0
Bath City FC - Brighton & Hove Albion 0:1
Bristol City - Charlton Athletic 2:3
Bury FC - Bolton Wanderers 1:1
Liverpool FC - Leyton Orient 2:1
Watford FC - Birmingham City 2:1
Gillingham FC - Swansea Town 1:4
Nottingham Forest - Reading FC 1:0
Aston Villa - Leeds United 2:1
Sheffield Wednesday - Middlesbrough FC 2:1
Crewe Alexandra - Workington AFC 2:0
West Bromwich Albion - Plymouth Argyle 3:2
Sunderland AFC - Blackburn Rovers 1:1
Derby County - Manchester United 2:4
Lincoln City - Burnley FC 1:1
Wrexham AFC - Leicester City 1:2
Sheffield United - Portsmouth FC 3:0
Ipswich Town - Peterborough United 2:3
Newport County - Wolverhampton Wanderers 2:2
Manchester City - Southampton FC 1:5
Fulham FC - Hull City 5:0
Bristol Rovers - Doncaster Rovers 0:0
Bradford City - Everton FC 3:0
Chelsea FC - Bradford Park Avenue 5:1
Exeter City - Luton Town 1:2
Scunthorpe United - Crystal Palace 1:0
Huddersfield Town - West Ham United 1:1
Cardiff City - Port Vale FC 0:2
Newport County - Tottenham Hotspur 0:4
Stoke City - Preston North End 1:1
Rotherham United - Arsenal FC 2:2
Entscheidungsspiele
12.01.1960 Burnley FC - Lincoln City 2:0
Doncaster Rovers - Bristol Rovers 1:2
Preston North End - Stoke City 3:1
13.01.1960 Bolton Wanderers - Bury FC 4:2
Blackburn Rovers - Sunderland AFC 4:1
Wolverhampton Wanderers - Newcastle United 4:2
West Ham United - Huddersfield Town 1:5
Arsenal FC - Rotherham United 1:1
18.01.1960 Rotherham United - Arsenal FC 2:0